3 Post Moderation Rule for New Boarders (25 Jan 2021)
New boarders will have their posts moderated - Don't worry if you cannot see your post immediately.
Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
02 Feb 2012 23:55 - 02 Feb 2012 23:57 #3777
by dgwvideo
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange was created by dgwvideo
Not sure what to make of this. I have a fairly complex compound clip of just over 1 minute length that usually plays fine in the timeline when it's broken apart to reveal clip items. When I then create a compound clip from it, it plays differently. The end seems to lose video at the last 2 seconds and some of the transitions do not work. If I break apart clip items, it usually is fine again. I say usually, because on a few occasions I've noticed some of the transitions maintain the proper clip effect for the first half of the transition but remove the effect on the second half.
I'm pulling my hair out trying to get the compound clip to play right once I get it right as individual clips in the timeline.
I just installed 10.0.3 and prior to doing that trashed all FCPX preferences so the new version could create fresh prefs. I also repaired permissions, etc., etc. before installing the fcpx upgrade. Also installed the latest lion update before running fcpx for the first time.
I let fcpx update the project as requested when it first opened.
Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.
I'm pulling my hair out trying to get the compound clip to play right once I get it right as individual clips in the timeline.
I just installed 10.0.3 and prior to doing that trashed all FCPX preferences so the new version could create fresh prefs. I also repaired permissions, etc., etc. before installing the fcpx upgrade. Also installed the latest lion update before running fcpx for the first time.
I let fcpx update the project as requested when it first opened.
Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Last edit: 02 Feb 2012 23:57 by dgwvideo. Reason: correct typo
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Feb 2012 00:03 - 03 Feb 2012 00:04 #3779
by BenB
Replied by BenB on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
Trash all the render files via the File menu, also. Be sure Events/Projects are not on the system drive. Not able to recreate this, but there's obviously a bug somewhere.
If you open the Compound Clip into it's own Timeline, does it play correctly there?
If you open the Compound Clip into it's own Timeline, does it play correctly there?
Last edit: 03 Feb 2012 00:04 by BenB.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Feb 2012 00:12 #3782
by dgwvideo
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Replied by dgwvideo on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
Well, for the most part it plays there OK, but like I said, occasionally it produces a loss of video, or an effect that doesn't work right. I can usually correct this but then when it becomes compound again it doesn't work right.
I have not been able to delete unused render files as I get the beachball spinning (left it for up to 30 minutes) every time I tried. I have not tried deleting all, but I will later this evening.
I have not been able to delete unused render files as I get the beachball spinning (left it for up to 30 minutes) every time I tried. I have not tried deleting all, but I will later this evening.
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Feb 2012 00:20 #3783
by BenB
Replied by BenB on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
If you get the lollypop when deleting render files via the File menu, there's a larger problem. Quite and delete render files manually then. Both for the Project and the Event.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Feb 2012 00:35 #3785
by dgwvideo
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Replied by dgwvideo on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
OK, I'll try that when I get back and report here.
Also, some added info in case it is relevant:
This clip consists mostly of 720 24p footage but does contain some motion-jpeg 640x480 clips which I rate conformed to 23.98. They were reported in FCPX as 29.34 fps and 29.42 fps (odd, but then again these were supplied to me from footage taken from a Kodac still/motion camera.) I have them layered into a 720p project with multiple effects and some basic color correction applied to them. I used optical flow on them, but since changed that to FLOOR. Perhaps this combination of footage and processing is the culprit. I have some RED highlights in the timeline bar which I haven't seen before above a few of these clips (not orange render bars, red coloring of the timeline top border).
Also, some added info in case it is relevant:
This clip consists mostly of 720 24p footage but does contain some motion-jpeg 640x480 clips which I rate conformed to 23.98. They were reported in FCPX as 29.34 fps and 29.42 fps (odd, but then again these were supplied to me from footage taken from a Kodac still/motion camera.) I have them layered into a 720p project with multiple effects and some basic color correction applied to them. I used optical flow on them, but since changed that to FLOOR. Perhaps this combination of footage and processing is the culprit. I have some RED highlights in the timeline bar which I haven't seen before above a few of these clips (not orange render bars, red coloring of the timeline top border).
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Feb 2012 00:47 #3787
by BenB
Replied by BenB on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
Are these clips all optimized?
Red eh? I'd love to see a screen shot of that!
Red eh? I'd love to see a screen shot of that!
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Feb 2012 00:51 #3788
by dgwvideo
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Replied by dgwvideo on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
Yes, these clips have all been imported Prores 422. I will do a screen capture tonight and post it with my response. Funny thing is, if I select the clip in question and change optical flow to floor, for example, the red band goes away, I'm presented with the orange render bar, it promptly renders and the red band returns. I am thinking this may be some indication by FCPX that the underlying clip has been rate conformed, retimed, etc. perhaps.
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Feb 2012 07:38 - 03 Feb 2012 07:38 #3795
by dgwvideo
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Replied by dgwvideo on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
Hey, BenB...
Here are some screenshots of the red bands you wanted to see.
The first one shows them over the compound clip in the timeline.
The second shows the band over the broken apart clips.
The third is a closeup of the band in the timeline bar where the TC is.
Here are some screenshots of the red bands you wanted to see.
The first one shows them over the compound clip in the timeline.
The second shows the band over the broken apart clips.
The third is a closeup of the band in the timeline bar where the TC is.
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Last edit: 03 Feb 2012 07:38 by dgwvideo. Reason: typo
Please Log in to join the conversation.
04 Feb 2012 01:02 #3828
by BenB
Replied by BenB on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
Wow. Wonder if this is a .0.3 thing. When my studio is back online tomorrow I'll try to duplicate. Down for renovations.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
04 Feb 2012 03:26 - 04 Feb 2012 03:27 #3834
by dgwvideo
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Replied by dgwvideo on topic Re: Compound Clip in 10.0.3 acts strange
Well, it wasn't introduced in 0.3 because it was occurring in 0.2 on this clip I was working on for over a week. I still think it may have something to do with indicating the underlying clips having been retimed or optical flow applied (perhaps in addition to effects). I only noticed this after setting optical flow and then subsequently changing that on the same clip. But this link may indicate it represents a freeze frame during a retime (although it appears in the animation editor while mine is showing up in the timecode section of the timeline border).
www.premiumbeat.com/blog/fcpx-trick-crea...g-the-retiming-tool/
I did use some effects which freeze a couple frames of video before they release the full effect.
Benb, Your advice to manually remove my render files really helped with this clip. It now plays perfect every time in the timeline. There is still one small issue - when I turn it into a compound clip, it plays fine except for one of the short clips in the middle jumps to the beginning of my storyline. When I break the compound apart, I can see that and have to move it back to where it belongs. Other than that one thing, FCPX now runs much better and no other issues arise as far as I can tell. I think somehow the clip got corrupted somewhere but everything looks OK when I break it apart, so I am leaving it like that. I should also mention that the compound clip contains several other compound clips nested within it. Don't know if this could be an issue.
www.premiumbeat.com/blog/fcpx-trick-crea...g-the-retiming-tool/
I did use some effects which freeze a couple frames of video before they release the full effect.
Benb, Your advice to manually remove my render files really helped with this clip. It now plays perfect every time in the timeline. There is still one small issue - when I turn it into a compound clip, it plays fine except for one of the short clips in the middle jumps to the beginning of my storyline. When I break the compound apart, I can see that and have to move it back to where it belongs. Other than that one thing, FCPX now runs much better and no other issues arise as far as I can tell. I think somehow the clip got corrupted somewhere but everything looks OK when I break it apart, so I am leaving it like that. I should also mention that the compound clip contains several other compound clips nested within it. Don't know if this could be an issue.
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Last edit: 04 Feb 2012 03:27 by dgwvideo. Reason: typo
Please Log in to join the conversation.


