- Posts: 65
- Thank you received: 1
3 Post Moderation Rule for New Boarders (25 Jan 2021)
New boarders will have their posts moderated - Don't worry if you cannot see your post immediately.
DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
24 Feb 2020 09:01 - 24 Feb 2020 09:01 #104873
by Michi
DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos) was created by Michi
Hell fellow FCPX users
I need to create a DVD master from a documentary with switchable subtitles / closed captions and a switchable audio-description track.
After trying different demo-versions of authoring apps and scanning the web I get the impression that no authoring application exists for Mac that does these things.
While it seems Encore did that just fine, it is EOL and not accessible anymore (and probably wouldn't run on Catalina anyway).Then there are some solutions that cost upwards of 15'000$ and are used for big budget productions. But those are not an option for budget reasons.
Does anybody use something else that does what I need or will I have to find a authoring service?
Any ideas or suggestions highly appreciated!
I need to create a DVD master from a documentary with switchable subtitles / closed captions and a switchable audio-description track.
After trying different demo-versions of authoring apps and scanning the web I get the impression that no authoring application exists for Mac that does these things.
While it seems Encore did that just fine, it is EOL and not accessible anymore (and probably wouldn't run on Catalina anyway).Then there are some solutions that cost upwards of 15'000$ and are used for big budget productions. But those are not an option for budget reasons.
Does anybody use something else that does what I need or will I have to find a authoring service?
Any ideas or suggestions highly appreciated!
Last edit: 24 Feb 2020 09:01 by Michi.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
24 Feb 2020 17:40 #104892
by Sefanzed
Replied by Sefanzed on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
I have the same issue. Every year my clients require DVDs for business conferences and showrooms. I've also searched for solutions and the only option that works for me is to boot my 2013 mac pro from another hard drive with Sierra OS. That way I can run DVD Studio Pro to author and burn discs. Unfortunately, unless your clients are happy with menu formats akin to "My Vacation" there's little other options available. Other's I've spoken to have purchased older macs on Ebay to accomplish this task. Good Luck!
Please Log in to join the conversation.
25 Feb 2020 08:13 #104907
by Michi
Replied by Michi on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
I contacted somebody yesterday for an Authoring request. He first had a good laugh since nobody asked him for that service in years then said he'd need to look if his authoring-computer was still running. Guess what application he runs on that machine: DVD Studio Pro...
So... I know it's a dying format, but there's still a market nonetheless.
So... I know it's a dying format, but there's still a market nonetheless.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
25 Feb 2020 10:09 #104910
by JoeEditor
Replied by JoeEditor on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
Unfortunately, a market too small for anyone to profit off of authoring software. Which sucks for those needing to do this.
A colleague locally who does occasional DVD work still has set up a service, or contracts with a service that provides online video. He tells me he sells most of his DVD requests on it. Family downloads the video, or the company has employees use online video instead of DVDs. Product demos are now all online. Chaptered, too.
But, I'd assume if there really was a large enough market for DVD authoring app that was full-featured, Adobe would still be renting it's authoring app.
A colleague locally who does occasional DVD work still has set up a service, or contracts with a service that provides online video. He tells me he sells most of his DVD requests on it. Family downloads the video, or the company has employees use online video instead of DVDs. Product demos are now all online. Chaptered, too.
But, I'd assume if there really was a large enough market for DVD authoring app that was full-featured, Adobe would still be renting it's authoring app.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- DmitriZigany
-
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 730
- Thank you received: 26
25 Feb 2020 13:18 #104917
by DmitriZigany
Replied by DmitriZigany on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
I recently edited a whole Live concert that I shot that was gonna be released on DVD. Ended up telling them I couldn't do the authoring.
In my case the DVD was gonna be included for free with the live concert album so in that case it sort of make sense, I guess.
In my case the DVD was gonna be included for free with the live concert album so in that case it sort of make sense, I guess.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
25 Feb 2020 15:23 - 25 Feb 2020 15:23 #104921
by Michi
Replied by Michi on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
Yes, that's a perfectly valid scenario where a DVD does indeed make sense.
It will probably last longer than Blu Ray, simply because many, many households own a DVD-Player and never made the switch to BR (the most sold Blu Ray-Players are probably Play Stations).
If I buy a Blu Ray in a Store, they still always ask if I'm aware it is a Blu Ray and not a DVD....
It will probably last longer than Blu Ray, simply because many, many households own a DVD-Player and never made the switch to BR (the most sold Blu Ray-Players are probably Play Stations).
If I buy a Blu Ray in a Store, they still always ask if I'm aware it is a Blu Ray and not a DVD....
Last edit: 25 Feb 2020 15:23 by Michi.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
25 Feb 2020 22:14 #104936
by Redifer
Replied by Redifer on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
Encore should work on Catalina, as it's 64-bit.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
25 Feb 2020 23:07 #104941
by Michi
Replied by Michi on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
Thanks for telling, didn't know that.
I actually wanted to rent Encore but it seems to not be downloadable anymore on Adobes Website, at least not with a new subscription.
I actually wanted to rent Encore but it seems to not be downloadable anymore on Adobes Website, at least not with a new subscription.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 Feb 2020 10:11 #104949
by Redifer
Replied by Redifer on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
I believe you have to download CS6 so look in their legacy section.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 Feb 2020 11:52 #104953
by petersxs
Replied by petersxs on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
same here , i have to make a DVD's from time to Time from comedy shows i record , since here in Austria, Bluray is not so popular )
I still use DVD Studio Pro , and it works very good, can do all the things you stated above and need !
I keep an old Mac Pro 3.1( 2008 with 10.6.8.) for that purpose
( Also need FcP7 from time to time since FCPX still can't do everything FCP7 could ; )
think its easy to find an old mac pro or another bootdisk , but i would not know where to get DVD studio pro now ... sorry..opt being much help ...... but the Software is good ...
I still use DVD Studio Pro , and it works very good, can do all the things you stated above and need !
I keep an old Mac Pro 3.1( 2008 with 10.6.8.) for that purpose
( Also need FcP7 from time to time since FCPX still can't do everything FCP7 could ; )
think its easy to find an old mac pro or another bootdisk , but i would not know where to get DVD studio pro now ... sorry..opt being much help ...... but the Software is good ...
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 Feb 2020 16:27 #104964
by Michi
Replied by Michi on topic DVD Authoring on Mac (for more than home-videos)
Yes, that's the route I'm taking now too. Don't have DVD Studio Pro myself but found somebody that has it and will help me creating that DVD...
Please Log in to join the conversation.




