- Posts: 17
- Thank you received: 0
3 Post Moderation Rule for New Boarders (25 Jan 2021)
New boarders will have their posts moderated - Don't worry if you cannot see your post immediately.
FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
06 Jan 2020 16:47 #103749
by kofman
Hi all,
I have been making youtube videos for a few months of myself playing piano, recorded with iPhone 11 Pro and a separate mic. I have been syncing audio in FCP, and then editing the rest including titles, color correction etc on my iPad Pro with Lumafusion. Lumafusion was more simple than FCP and had less options which was easier for me to deal with when I started as a total beginner. But now I want to do more with color correction and exposure control, and need something more powerful so I told myself its time to learn how to do good color correction and other editing in final cut pro X.
I started watching some videos and beginner tutorials, some people base their tutorials and swear by Color Wheels, some say Color Board is best, and some people in their videos used just Color Curves for their tutorials. I followed different methods in tutorials, trying each color correction method and I’m just overwhelmed and want to focus on one thing. But it seems that most people say Color Wheels is the most “powerful”
In your opinion, as a total beginner which one should I focus on primarily and get good at and study? And are there any sites with tutorial with sample footage I can follow along with to experiment and learn with?
I have been making youtube videos for a few months of myself playing piano, recorded with iPhone 11 Pro and a separate mic. I have been syncing audio in FCP, and then editing the rest including titles, color correction etc on my iPad Pro with Lumafusion. Lumafusion was more simple than FCP and had less options which was easier for me to deal with when I started as a total beginner. But now I want to do more with color correction and exposure control, and need something more powerful so I told myself its time to learn how to do good color correction and other editing in final cut pro X.
I started watching some videos and beginner tutorials, some people base their tutorials and swear by Color Wheels, some say Color Board is best, and some people in their videos used just Color Curves for their tutorials. I followed different methods in tutorials, trying each color correction method and I’m just overwhelmed and want to focus on one thing. But it seems that most people say Color Wheels is the most “powerful”
In your opinion, as a total beginner which one should I focus on primarily and get good at and study? And are there any sites with tutorial with sample footage I can follow along with to experiment and learn with?
Please Log in to join the conversation.
06 Jan 2020 18:04 #103751
by arc
Replied by arc on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
As a Premiere Pro user first and FCPX users second I have to say I like the color correction tools in FCPX. They all work and can be very effective. Use what works best for you. Don't worry about what other people prefer.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
07 Jan 2020 00:18 #103755
by dgwvideo
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Replied by dgwvideo on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
There are several free color correction training tutorials online if you google "color correction in FCPX". You might watch a few of these, but I would highly recommend Ripple Training color correction tutorials for more consistent learning and interacting with sample footage. I generally prefer using color wheels, but there are many times that curves have benefits and I almost never use the color board anymore. The color board is a bit more limited but will suffice for most basic corrections. This is largely preference and once you know basic color correction you will understand the UI for each method you mentioned and how to use them.
Creating history....one edit at a time !
Please Log in to join the conversation.
07 Jan 2020 02:15 #103757
by JoeEditor
Replied by JoeEditor on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
Each tool has a purpose (except the color board which I will never like at all). As suggested, and I second, take a proper color grading course. But the process is always the same. I teach color grading and suggest Ripple.
1- white balance
2- contrast
3- correct for memory colors
1- white balance
2- contrast
3- correct for memory colors
Please Log in to join the conversation.
07 Jan 2020 08:32 #103770
by Axel
Replied by Axel on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
Color Wheels:
Good for adjusting colors in Global, Highlights, Midtones and Shadows. But you have to understand that their ranges overlap.
Curves:
You can set an exact point, indeed many points, below or above which you want to bend them. So for example if you want to lift the range just beneath the skin tones without affecting those, you better do this with curves.
Color Board:
An FCPX / iMovie special. Fastest way to pretty intuitively color correct, and in this respect totally underrated. Doesn't encourage you to dive deeper but tends to deliver pleasing results. Whereas someone who is overwhelmed by too many options often destroys the image.
Besides knowing what the specific tools do, you need to establish a reasonable workflow (see FCPX guru).
Good for adjusting colors in Global, Highlights, Midtones and Shadows. But you have to understand that their ranges overlap.
Curves:
You can set an exact point, indeed many points, below or above which you want to bend them. So for example if you want to lift the range just beneath the skin tones without affecting those, you better do this with curves.
Color Board:
An FCPX / iMovie special. Fastest way to pretty intuitively color correct, and in this respect totally underrated. Doesn't encourage you to dive deeper but tends to deliver pleasing results. Whereas someone who is overwhelmed by too many options often destroys the image.
Besides knowing what the specific tools do, you need to establish a reasonable workflow (see FCPX guru).
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Karsten Schlüter
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 3790
- Thank you received: 718
07 Jan 2020 09:27 #103773
by Karsten Schlüter
Replied by Karsten Schlüter on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
Superb summary, Axel, chapeau!
I also recommend the tuts from RippleTraining (the free ones on YT, as the commercial ones).
As a beginner, you have - independently of what UserInterface! - to understand the concept how video/photography handles ‘color’.
Only then you’ll understand, what happens when you push some puck in some Interface…
And: the Scope is your friend, in any form of Color Processing.
Personal experience: used, as a beginner, for years the ColorBoard = reduced interface to the max. Meanwhile a fan of curves (alone that puck-by-pick feature - now, that is intuitive!)
I also recommend the tuts from RippleTraining (the free ones on YT, as the commercial ones).
As a beginner, you have - independently of what UserInterface! - to understand the concept how video/photography handles ‘color’.
Only then you’ll understand, what happens when you push some puck in some Interface…
And: the Scope is your friend, in any form of Color Processing.
Personal experience: used, as a beginner, for years the ColorBoard = reduced interface to the max. Meanwhile a fan of curves (alone that puck-by-pick feature - now, that is intuitive!)
Please Log in to join the conversation.
07 Jan 2020 18:03 #103777
by kofman
Replied by kofman on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
Thanks guys, this is truly one of the most amazing forums
Please Log in to join the conversation.
07 Jan 2020 22:05 #103781
by Redifer
Replied by Redifer on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
I used to be of the school that makes sure blacks are properly black before I make sure the whites are white. But with the Hue/Saturation Curves panel I don't really need to do that any more. Still, I shoot in LOG so I always have to make sure to push the blacks down and raise the whites high before I do anything.
This is perhaps the most racist post I've ever written.
This is perhaps the most racist post I've ever written.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
08 Jan 2020 06:34 #103786
by Axel
Replied by Axel on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
Redifer wrote:
This is perhaps the most racist post I've ever written.
Did you notice the ambiguity afterwards? Wouldn’t have struck me if you hadn’t added that sentence.
There is an explanation by Larry Jordan why colorists need to be, er, colorblind and not believe in races in the first place: all human’s skin is on the skintone line in the vectorscope because their blood is the same red. There are billions of luma variations.
This is perhaps the most racist post I've ever written.
Did you notice the ambiguity afterwards? Wouldn’t have struck me if you hadn’t added that sentence.
There is an explanation by Larry Jordan why colorists need to be, er, colorblind and not believe in races in the first place: all human’s skin is on the skintone line in the vectorscope because their blood is the same red. There are billions of luma variations.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
12 Jan 2020 10:21 #103862
by Redifer
Replied by Redifer on topic FCPX Color Wheels vs Color Board vs Color Curves for beginners?
Ha! I had never thought of it that way. Actually really interesting to think about.
Please Log in to join the conversation.




