- Posts: 45
- Thank you received: 0
3 Post Moderation Rule for New Boarders (25 Jan 2021)
New boarders will have their posts moderated - Don't worry if you cannot see your post immediately.
FCPX Plugin to remove Sensor Dirt?
07 Mar 2019 19:50 #99202
by truelife2
FCPX Plugin to remove Sensor Dirt? was created by truelife2
I've been scouring the internet for some way to remove sensor dirt from a moving shot in FCPX. Somehow our A7S got dirty while moving around on a gimbal and the footage has a dark spot, dead center. Is there a way to deal with this? Again the shot is moving so the normal duplicate layer and blur methods don't really work. I tried the CHV Repair plugin but it doesn't seem to work...
Any thoughts?
Any thoughts?
Please Log in to join the conversation.
07 Mar 2019 21:07 #99204
by joema
This is a difficult case and nothing works really well. CoreMelt's object remover can handle some cases but a moving shot is hard: coremelt.com/pages/slicex-remove-objects
Their newer PaintX tool might also handle some cases but I haven't tried it: coremelt.com/products/paintx-powered-by-mocha
If really desperate you can export each frame and fix them one by one in Photoshop. For anything other than a brief shot that's a huge amount of work. This can be good motivation to check equipment and lenses before each important shot.
Sensor and lens dirt is much more apparent when shooting at smaller (numerical higher) apertures. A good way to avoid this is shoot at wider apertures, which means using an ND filter outdoors.
Replied by joema on topic FCPX Plugin to remove Sensor Dirt?
truelife2 wrote: I've been scouring the internet for some way to remove sensor dirt from a moving shot in FCPX....the shot is moving so the normal duplicate layer and blur methods don't really work...
This is a difficult case and nothing works really well. CoreMelt's object remover can handle some cases but a moving shot is hard: coremelt.com/pages/slicex-remove-objects
Their newer PaintX tool might also handle some cases but I haven't tried it: coremelt.com/products/paintx-powered-by-mocha
If really desperate you can export each frame and fix them one by one in Photoshop. For anything other than a brief shot that's a huge amount of work. This can be good motivation to check equipment and lenses before each important shot.
Sensor and lens dirt is much more apparent when shooting at smaller (numerical higher) apertures. A good way to avoid this is shoot at wider apertures, which means using an ND filter outdoors.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
07 Mar 2019 21:14 #99205
by truelife2
Replied by truelife2 on topic FCPX Plugin to remove Sensor Dirt?
Thanks, Joema. Yeah, exporting each frame seems painful, but I suppose it may be cheaper than getting someone to scope it out.
I also tried Neat Video and it seemed to work, but then when the shot moved it stopped working...
I also tried Neat Video and it seemed to work, but then when the shot moved it stopped working...
Please Log in to join the conversation.
08 Mar 2019 01:59 #99208
by JoeEditor
Replied by JoeEditor on topic FCPX Plugin to remove Sensor Dirt?
I use PaintX for this more often than I care to admit. Highly recommended!
Please Log in to join the conversation.
08 Mar 2019 02:44 #99211
by truelife2
Replied by truelife2 on topic FCPX Plugin to remove Sensor Dirt?
FCPX.guru I'd be curious if you were using this on moving shots or only static shots? I used TrackX to some success, but being that my shots are all gimbal shots, the background is constantly changing. If I drop a still into Photoshop I'm able to lighten the dark spot and make it a non-issue, so if I could do this in PaintX it'd be a treat.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
09 Mar 2019 15:13 - 09 Mar 2019 15:14 #99223
by JoeEditor
Replied by JoeEditor on topic FCPX Plugin to remove Sensor Dirt?
I use PaintX on video clips. Great to have paint/clone tools with Mocha tracking built-in. I'm doing some example videos, to be published soon, of our work at the TV station using PaintX soon for Coremelt.
Now you're talking grading, instead of covering a speck of dust on your lens/sensor. FCP's built-in color tools can have a mask that keyframes. But I'd use Chromatic, as it comes with the Mocha tracker built-in.
Now you're talking grading, instead of covering a speck of dust on your lens/sensor. FCP's built-in color tools can have a mask that keyframes. But I'd use Chromatic, as it comes with the Mocha tracker built-in.
Last edit: 09 Mar 2019 15:14 by JoeEditor.
Please Log in to join the conversation.




