- Posts: 272
- Thank you received: 2
3 Post Moderation Rule for New Boarders (25 Jan 2021)
New boarders will have their posts moderated - Don't worry if you cannot see your post immediately.
Most efficient and lossless way to import TS files?
03 Apr 2018 02:19 #94954
by Slaughter
Most efficient and lossless way to import TS files? was created by Slaughter
I have searched the forum for "TS", but this fails as the search includes words including these letters together - so apologies if this is already covered here.
I want to - as losslessly as possible - import sections of a TS file. It's a HD TV capture. I only want to use a tiny 2 min section. It's incredibly arduous given that FCPX can't read TS files.
mpegstreamclip cannot read the file (a known issue). I have had to run the whole thing through handbrake, converting a 3.7GB TS file into an 11GB mp4 (again, I want to minimise loss so used maximum settings).
You can't select sections in handbrake, only the whole dang file. So even more arduous. Now mpegstreamclip can read this massive mp4 file, but the 2 minutes I want to use is turning out to be a massive file when I tell mpegstreamclip to use max. settings. As I write this, it has taken 20 minutes to convert about 1/3 of this 2 minute selection I have made.
I need to minimise loss of video quality. How do others here manage TS files for use in FCPX when video quality is of paramount importance?
Cheers
I want to - as losslessly as possible - import sections of a TS file. It's a HD TV capture. I only want to use a tiny 2 min section. It's incredibly arduous given that FCPX can't read TS files.
mpegstreamclip cannot read the file (a known issue). I have had to run the whole thing through handbrake, converting a 3.7GB TS file into an 11GB mp4 (again, I want to minimise loss so used maximum settings).
You can't select sections in handbrake, only the whole dang file. So even more arduous. Now mpegstreamclip can read this massive mp4 file, but the 2 minutes I want to use is turning out to be a massive file when I tell mpegstreamclip to use max. settings. As I write this, it has taken 20 minutes to convert about 1/3 of this 2 minute selection I have made.
I need to minimise loss of video quality. How do others here manage TS files for use in FCPX when video quality is of paramount importance?
Cheers
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Apr 2018 09:46 #94957
by joema
Replied by joema on topic Most efficient and lossless way to import TS files?
You can trim the file using either Quicktime Player or VLC. Quicktime seems to re-encoded it using H264, whereas TS files are MPEG-2. You'd have to examine the file for quality. See this page under "Edit":
support.apple.com/en-us/HT201066
VLC seems to maintain the current codec, the output is a small TS file, which you could then rapidly convert with Handbrake. Unfortunately VLC requires you play the material at 1x speed, but for only 2 min that's probably OK.
1. Set VLC output folder: VLC>Preferences>Input/Codecs>Record directory or filename
2. Play video in VLC, skip to beginning of region to trim
3. OPT+CMD+R to start recording
4. OPT+CMD+R to stop recording
5. Trimmed TS file will be in above folder
VLC seems to maintain the current codec, the output is a small TS file, which you could then rapidly convert with Handbrake. Unfortunately VLC requires you play the material at 1x speed, but for only 2 min that's probably OK.
1. Set VLC output folder: VLC>Preferences>Input/Codecs>Record directory or filename
2. Play video in VLC, skip to beginning of region to trim
3. OPT+CMD+R to start recording
4. OPT+CMD+R to stop recording
5. Trimmed TS file will be in above folder
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Roadswitcher
-
- Offline
- Senior Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 56
- Thank you received: 4
03 Apr 2018 20:43 #94964
by Roadswitcher
Replied by Roadswitcher on topic Most efficient and lossless way to import TS files?
ff-Works ( ex iFFmpeg ) will be your best friend for that, using the rewrap of your ts file. It's a very fast operation, no transcoding involved, only the container and the file extension are changed.
But if you want, you can trim the file before rewrapping it.
Can't remember if Edit Ready ( from ClipWrap fame ) also accepts .ts files, but they take mts files in, possibly also m2ts files.
But if you want, you can trim the file before rewrapping it.
Can't remember if Edit Ready ( from ClipWrap fame ) also accepts .ts files, but they take mts files in, possibly also m2ts files.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
03 Apr 2018 23:38 #94966
by Slaughter
That looks perfect - and it's affordable! Thanks.
Replied by Slaughter on topic Most efficient and lossless way to import TS files?
Roadswitcher wrote: ff-Works ( ex iFFmpeg ) will be your best friend for that, using the rewrap of your ts file. It's a very fast operation, no transcoding involved, only the container and the file extension are changed.
But if you want, you can trim the file before rewrapping it.
Can't remember if Edit Ready ( from ClipWrap fame ) also accepts .ts files, but they take mts files in, possibly also m2ts files.
That looks perfect - and it's affordable! Thanks.
Please Log in to join the conversation.



