- Posts: 145
- Thank you received: 1
3 Post Moderation Rule for New Boarders (25 Jan 2021)
New boarders will have their posts moderated - Don't worry if you cannot see your post immediately.
comparison on video quality
26 May 2017 13:35 #88360
by owenpga
comparison on video quality was created by owenpga
trying to figure out how i should be importing videos into final cut. (proxy+opt, proxy, or original)
I'm doing very basic video with some transitions, tweaking color, exposure and sharpening. nothing elaborate.
so i took the same video clip an imported them 3 ways
1st. original import with no opt or proxy checked.
2nd. proxy only
3rd. opt only
all edits the same
i exported them all as 1080 h.264
they all look about the same in quality to me. the opt version may be a touch better.
What should be the order of quality on final output?
any advantages or disadvantages on the different imports with the kind of editing I'm doing?
All editing is done on more powerful mac pro, so no laptop stuff.
thanks
I'm doing very basic video with some transitions, tweaking color, exposure and sharpening. nothing elaborate.
so i took the same video clip an imported them 3 ways
1st. original import with no opt or proxy checked.
2nd. proxy only
3rd. opt only
all edits the same
i exported them all as 1080 h.264
they all look about the same in quality to me. the opt version may be a touch better.
What should be the order of quality on final output?
any advantages or disadvantages on the different imports with the kind of editing I'm doing?
All editing is done on more powerful mac pro, so no laptop stuff.
thanks
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Tom Wolsky
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
26 May 2017 13:48 #88361
by Tom Wolsky
Replied by Tom Wolsky on topic comparison on video quality
How you import depends on your computer specs and the specs of the incoming media.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 May 2017 14:29 #88363
by owenpga
Replied by owenpga on topic comparison on video quality
3.33 GHz 6-Core Intel Xeon
32gig ram
1 T SSD
2T raid 1 OWC HD
4k import at 30p
1080 imports at 60p
32gig ram
1 T SSD
2T raid 1 OWC HD
4k import at 30p
1080 imports at 60p
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Tom Wolsky
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
26 May 2017 14:30 #88364
by Tom Wolsky
Replied by Tom Wolsky on topic comparison on video quality
I'd just import the originals, no proxy or optimized.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 May 2017 14:36 #88366
by owenpga
Replied by owenpga on topic comparison on video quality
thanks Tom.
from an overall quality standpoint , ultimately sending video via compressor to youtube
would optimized make any difference in the final output?
thanks
from an overall quality standpoint , ultimately sending video via compressor to youtube
would optimized make any difference in the final output?
thanks
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 May 2017 14:40 #88369
by JoeEditor
Replied by JoeEditor on topic comparison on video quality
No, it will not. Transcoding to another codec never "improves" what is recorded on the original video. The original is the best quality you can possibly have.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Tom Wolsky
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
26 May 2017 14:40 #88370
by Tom Wolsky
Replied by Tom Wolsky on topic comparison on video quality
No.
Please Log in to join the conversation.


