- Posts: 120
- Thank you received: 3
3 Post Moderation Rule for New Boarders (25 Jan 2021)
New boarders will have their posts moderated - Don't worry if you cannot see your post immediately.
Freeze Frame Cloning?
26 May 2017 02:34 - 26 May 2017 02:40 #88344
by thinkfilm
Replied by thinkfilm on topic Freeze Frame Cloning?
The effect in this video is an elaborately choreographed version of what Ben Balser demonstrates in his Future Freeze Frame tutorial - see here:
finalcutprox.guru/videos-main/fcpx-videos/fcpx-videos.html
Last edit: 26 May 2017 02:40 by thinkfilm.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Karsten Schlüter
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 3790
- Thank you received: 718
26 May 2017 06:11 #88347
by Karsten Schlüter
gosh, Feb 2013 … time flies by
Not my idea, but you will do hard to find a site using that expression 'Future Freeze' before my publication
No, not in FCPX but in Motion, did that without any plug-in, simply using the MatchMove/'Tracker' on Motion 5 and using Pixelmator for the cut-out …
Nice eye-candy …
Replied by Karsten Schlüter on topic Freeze Frame Cloning?
RayPaula wrote: …I would like to know if anyone has done this freeze frame cloning effect in FCPX?…
gosh, Feb 2013 … time flies by
Not my idea, but you will do hard to find a site using that expression 'Future Freeze' before my publication
No, not in FCPX but in Motion, did that without any plug-in, simply using the MatchMove/'Tracker' on Motion 5 and using Pixelmator for the cut-out …
Nice eye-candy …
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 May 2017 06:24 #88348
by Axel
Replied by Axel on topic Freeze Frame Cloning?
I agree that the Coremelt plugins let you do a lot of things right within FCP X. I tested them, and they are awesome. However, I didn't buy them 'cause they do have limitations.
Take the Thomas Rhett video above. It's a dolly/gimbal shot in which the masked freeze frame has to be scaled appropriately because the camera moves in the z-axis. The tracking data need to be better for this. It's not enough to track the x-y-position (i.e. of the chairs in Balsers tutorial), you have to extract the 3D camera positions in order to allow a still instance of the guy appearing oof in the foreground.
Therefore - as awkward and old-fashioned as it's GUI may be - I still consider After Effects the best app for these kinds of advanced tricks.
Moving lower thirds, tracked correction masks (if that's all you ask for): you'd be crazy not to use Coremelt.
Advanced motion graphics: Motion is simply the best, if as stand-alone or as template-programmer for FCP X.
Advanced compositing: After Effects.
My 2 cents.
Take the Thomas Rhett video above. It's a dolly/gimbal shot in which the masked freeze frame has to be scaled appropriately because the camera moves in the z-axis. The tracking data need to be better for this. It's not enough to track the x-y-position (i.e. of the chairs in Balsers tutorial), you have to extract the 3D camera positions in order to allow a still instance of the guy appearing oof in the foreground.
Therefore - as awkward and old-fashioned as it's GUI may be - I still consider After Effects the best app for these kinds of advanced tricks.
Moving lower thirds, tracked correction masks (if that's all you ask for): you'd be crazy not to use Coremelt.
Advanced motion graphics: Motion is simply the best, if as stand-alone or as template-programmer for FCP X.
Advanced compositing: After Effects.
My 2 cents.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 May 2017 10:16 #88351
by RayPaula
Replied by RayPaula on topic Freeze Frame Cloning?
Thanks for your input..... I have a little better understanding now of how it's done. I'll have to play around a bit once I get up and running. I do have Coremelt Slice X & TrackX, but haven't used it yet. I'm a newbie in learning FCPX coming from Sony Vegas Pro. I do have Ripple training videos in which I'm currently going through. Thanks again to all of you for your help & input, very much appreciated. Ray
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 May 2017 12:08 #88353
by thinkfilm
Replied by thinkfilm on topic Freeze Frame Cloning?
Karsten and Axel - of course you are both correct about this. The video that RayPaula mentioned depicts a sophisticated version of the "Future Freeze" effect that would not be feasibly executed in FCP X for the reasons Axel mentions. Looks to my eye too that there are a couple of other intricate things happening in the video to enhance the effect - maybe using Mocha Pro or other tools, along with After Effects. It's well-choreographed like some of the OKgo videos.
RayPaula, FCPX using Coremelt's tracking plugins does give you the basic idea of what's going here - it's just this video is a pretty sophisticated.
RayPaula, FCPX using Coremelt's tracking plugins does give you the basic idea of what's going here - it's just this video is a pretty sophisticated.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
26 May 2017 12:59 #88355
by JoeEditor
Replied by JoeEditor on topic Freeze Frame Cloning?
Back when Coremelt introduced SliceX and TrackX at NAB (forget the year) I was invited to hang out at their booth and show off this exact same effects. Way easier than you think. No Motion or AE necessary. Karsten basically has it down.
Please Log in to join the conversation.



