- Posts: 63
- Thank you received: 0
3 Post Moderation Rule for New Boarders (25 Jan 2021)
New boarders will have their posts moderated - Don't worry if you cannot see your post immediately.
Clicking noise added to audio
27 Mar 2015 13:06 #61978
by Dinky
Clicking noise added to audio was created by Dinky
I have copied MTS files from an SD card to hard disk and imported these into the FCPX library as external files. When I play the clips directly from the browser (e.g. using VLC) the audio is fine. The imported files in FCPX, however,contain random clicking. This will also ultimately be in the final exported movie.
I am using FCPX 10.1.4 running on OSX 10.9.5
Does anybody else have a similar problem and, if so, is there a solution ? I have reported the issue to Apple, but nothing happens there.
The attached file contains the clicking noise. The original MTS does not have that.
I am using FCPX 10.1.4 running on OSX 10.9.5
Does anybody else have a similar problem and, if so, is there a solution ? I have reported the issue to Apple, but nothing happens there.
The attached file contains the clicking noise. The original MTS does not have that.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Tom Wolsky
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
27 Mar 2015 13:11 #61979
by Tom Wolsky
Replied by Tom Wolsky on topic Clicking noise added to audio
Did you optimize the media? You really do need to optimize raw mts files.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
27 Mar 2015 13:27 - 27 Mar 2015 14:30 #61981
by Dinky
Replied by Dinky on topic Clicking noise added to audio
Yes, I did
interestingly: if I import WITHOUT creating optimized media, the clicking will NOT occur. Therefor my conclusion is that the optimization process corrupts the audio
Additional problem is, that the clicking can be reduced by setting the background noise removal to 10% or so, but then the audio will contain a volume dip where the click was. This gives an unpleasant "pulsating" kind of sound, so that is unusable.
More info: I just did a small test using a clip with the clicking problem in iMovie: absolutely no problem. So it is definitively an FCPX issue.
interestingly: if I import WITHOUT creating optimized media, the clicking will NOT occur. Therefor my conclusion is that the optimization process corrupts the audio
Additional problem is, that the clicking can be reduced by setting the background noise removal to 10% or so, but then the audio will contain a volume dip where the click was. This gives an unpleasant "pulsating" kind of sound, so that is unusable.
More info: I just did a small test using a clip with the clicking problem in iMovie: absolutely no problem. So it is definitively an FCPX issue.
Last edit: 27 Mar 2015 14:30 by Dinky.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
27 Mar 2015 18:20 #62006
by Dinky
Replied by Dinky on topic Clicking noise added to audio
A way around this (be it a very cumbersome one) is:
1. Export the audio from the original footage, e.g. using VLC, to a format accepted by FCPX, e.g. AIFF or MP4
2. Import the exported audio file into the FCPX event, containing the clip from step 1
3. In FCPX select both the imported clip and the imported audio from step 2
4. Create a synchronized clip from these
5. Right click the newly created synchronized clip and select "Open in Time line"
6. In the time line mute the audio of the original clip, leaving you with the video of the original clip and the audio
from step 1, now in sync with the video
7. Use this synchronized clip in your final video
It's a pain in the neck to work around a problem that should not be there in the first place
1. Export the audio from the original footage, e.g. using VLC, to a format accepted by FCPX, e.g. AIFF or MP4
2. Import the exported audio file into the FCPX event, containing the clip from step 1
3. In FCPX select both the imported clip and the imported audio from step 2
4. Create a synchronized clip from these
5. Right click the newly created synchronized clip and select "Open in Time line"
6. In the time line mute the audio of the original clip, leaving you with the video of the original clip and the audio
from step 1, now in sync with the video
7. Use this synchronized clip in your final video
It's a pain in the neck to work around a problem that should not be there in the first place
Please Log in to join the conversation.

